You are watching: Dig behind the poster in a jail cell
naught is an ext infuriating (within the worlds of examining movies, at least) than once a nagging plot-hole ruins an otherwise perfect movie but, fortunately, this isn"t the case with The Shawshank Redemption. Based on the Stephen King story Rita Hayworth & The Shawshank Redemption, open minded Darabont adapted this under-the-radar novella into an even much more under-the-radar movie that dropped flat at the box office. Thankfully, The Shawshank Redemption did attract vital acclaim and also award nominations and has due to the fact that become a bona fide classic thanks to rentals, VHS and cable TV airings. In 2020, The Shawshank Redemption is widely considered one the the finest stories ever before put come film.
Starring Tim Robbins and Morgan Freeman, Andy Dufresne (Robbins) is mistakenly sent come jail for murdering his cheating wife and also her illicit lover. A experienced man thrust into a human being of criminals and also violence, Dufresne befriends jail yard lifer Red (Freeman) and also uses his economic nous to do prison at the very least somewhat bearable, despite facing the corruption and also unsavory varieties one would suppose to find behind bars. The Shawshank Redemption"s best trick is luring the audience right into thinking Dufresne"s story is around a male accepting his unjust punishment once it"s actually a tale about quiet resistance and unwavering determination.
Related: Stephen King Theory: the & The Shawshank Redemption room Connected
The Shawshank Redemption has actually been praised for its performances, script, cinematography, and direction, for this reason it"s incredibly annoying once someone points out a minor plot-hole that ultimately becomes among those glaring, impossible to un-see goofs. However even though The Shawshank Redemption"s long-debated error has gained plenty that attention, the equipment is best there on the screen, proving the Frank Darabont is still outsmarting viewers part 26 year later. Here"s why The Shawshank Redemption"s plot-hole around a feet isn"t a plot-hole at all.
after earning some level of pull v prison officials, Andy Dufresne is permitted a poster of Raquel Welch for his cell and some small tools to carve sculptures from jail yard stones. The Shawshank Redemption"s huge twist reveals that over a expectations of numerous years, Dufresne secretly offered this minute absent hammer come tunnel an escape route from his cabinet to the sewage system system. The vast poster the Raquel Welch from One Million year B.C. is used to covering the increasingly deep feet in Andy"s cell, maintaining the banker"s escape plan a secret for an impressive total of 19 years. The expose is made once Shawshank"s warden investigates Dufresne"s empty lodgings and starts cram rocks in anger. One projectile hits Ms. Welch and tears straight through, revealing the cavernous tunnel behind it. A classic, timeless movie moment of the greatest order... But how on planet did Andy Dufresne reattach the poster indigenous inside the tunnel?
Every night because that 19 years, Dufresne would"ve eliminated the poster, hammered far at his tunnel, returned right into his cell, and then fixed Welch ago to the wall surface once again. Yet the fateful night of his actual escape, Andy climbs right into the feet and, v all the decision in the world, couldn"t have actually physically re-fixed his poster to the wall surface from within the cavity. In real life, Andy certain would"ve been forced to leave his escape course exposed, through the poster discarded ~ above the cell floor. Obviously, this wouldn"t be everywhere near as dramatic as Norton hurling the rock, and some have accused The Shawshank Redemption of prioritizing dramatic influence over storytelling logic.
everything your opinions on The big Bang Theory, the sitcom does sell a few pearls that wisdom top top movie culture, and one episode sees Jim Parsons" Sheldon learn around a glaring plot-hole in Raiders the the lost Ark. For the remainder that the episode, Sheldon no hope tries come prove that his lover Indiana Jones movie is perfect, yet he simply can"t neglect the film"s deadly flaw. This is precisely why the positioning of Andy Dufresne"s poster is together a warm topic of conflict among The Shawshank Redemption fans. Together the extraordinary prison tale became an ext renowned in the so late 1990s and also early 2000s, critics began to hail The Shawshank Redemption as a perfect movie with no weak links. The fact that such a well-rounded and intelligently created movie with exemplary foreshadowing and also one of the biggest movie twisted of every time can be undone through a simple lapse of logic is incredibly annoying. Choose Tiger Woods shedding the U.S. Open due to the fact that he forgot which finish of the club to struggle with.
Related: Why Shawshank Redemption Is tho IMDb’s peak Rated Movie Of every Time
Andy Dufresne"s escape native Shawshank is improbable by its an extremely nature - that"s what makes The Shawshank Redemption"s finishing so uplifting. How didn"t anyone listen Andy digging? exactly how did the tunnel regulate to protect against pipes and also other obstacles? go none the the guards notification a draft emanating from Raquel Welch? However, these queries have plausible (albeit unspoken) explanations, ensuring Andy Dufresne"s jailbreak continues to be at least somewhat realistic. However attaching the poster earlier to the wall from inside the hole shows up to have actually no latent explanation, unraveling all of the difficult work behind The Shawshank Redemption"s ending.
Anyone tho rankled by Andy Dufresne"s logic-defying poster deserve to rest basic - The Shawshank Redemption provides a suitably plausible explanation for exactly how Raquel Welch uncovered her means back onto Andy"s cabinet wall following the banker"s dramatic departure. In order come avert apprehension from the top actress and the massive hole she was hiding, Andy inquiry an assortment of other posters to decorate his cell, including Einstein poking the end his tongue, Marilyn Monroe, and, together per Stephen King"s initial book, Rita Hayworth. Crucially, at least some of this posters space affixed through their peak corners only, with the bottom two hanging freely. This is a prison, ~ all, and also as privileged together Andy might"ve to be within Shawshank, difficult tape was undoubtedly difficult to come by. It renders sense that the cabinet posters would only be attached at the top, and knowing that Andy didn"t necessarily tape his pin-ups in ~ all four corners gives a potential explanation for the Raquel Welch plot-hole.
Essentially, that didn"t. Once the red mist descends and also Norton starts his tirade towards Red in Andy Dufresne"s empty cell, the camera gives only a quick shot that the Raquel Welch poster. In this moment, it"s clear the the photo is just taped to the wall on the right-hand side, vice versa, the left is hanging loose like Andy"s other posters. This method Andy could"ve slipped right into the tunnel with the open corner without removing any kind of of the 3 corners attached to the wall. The poster is plainly big sufficient to permit it. As soon as Andy to be safely behind Raquel, the poster would then flap ago down, covering his leave route and buying more time before the guards began their search. Andy might"ve gotten rid of the poster completely while he to be hammering away at his tunnel end the years, but during the to escape itself, it seems he simply lifted the solitary unfixed corner. Meanwhile, the 3 tape-recorded sides would"ve produced enough anxiety for the poster to rip when Norton launched a absent at it.
See more: March Into The Sea Lyrics - March Into The Sea By Modest Mouse
This scenario is still reasonably improbable. Exactly how did a grown guy squeeze behind the poster without damaging it, and would the poster really simply flop ago down into position? But as with every various other unanswered question about Andy"s escape, the audience can at least imagine their very own potential answers, and unlike reattaching the poster from inside, possible explanations do exist. The escape of Andy Dufresne in The Shawshank Redemption remains incredibly far-fetched, however as long as the breakout sits within the kingdom of reality, the movie"s finishing works. Andy didn"t re-tape the poster earlier to the wall surface after climbing right into his hand-made tunnel, meaning The Shawshank Redemption can go ago to being taken into consideration a perfect cinematic masterpiece.