The root reason of the American Civil battle is probably the many controversial topic in American history. Even prior to the battle was over, scholars in the North and South started to analyze and also interpret the factors behind the bloodshed.

You are watching: Southerners justified secession with the theory of


The scholars instantly disagreed over the causes of the war and also disagreement stubborn today. Countless maintain the the primary cause of the war was the southern states’ desire to keep the school of slavery. Rather minimize slavery and allude to other factors, together as taxes or the rule of States" Rights.

In 2011, in ~ the outset of the sesquicentennial, a Pew Research facility poll found that americans were considerably divided ~ above the issue, v 48% saying the war was "mainly about states" rights," 38% speak the war was "mainly about slavery," through the remainder comment "both equally" or "neither/don"t know." One technique by which to analyze this historical conflict is to focus on main sources. Every state in the Confederacy issued an “Article the Secession” proclaiming their break from the Union. Four states walk further. Texas, Mississippi, Georgia and also South Carolina all issued extr documents, usually referred to as the “Declarations the Causes," which explain their decision to leave the Union. Two significant themes arise in these documents: slavery and also states" rights. All 4 states strongly safeguard slavery while making varying claims related come states" rights. Other grievances, together as economic exploitation and also the role of the military, receive restricted attention in few of the documents. This article will present, in detail, everything that was claimed in the Declarations of reasons pertaining to these topics.

*
these charts show how countless words were dedicated to the worries raised in each state"s Declaration together a percent of the whole. "Context" describes procedural language and/or historic exposition the is not connected to a specific argument.
*
This native cloud shows the 50 words provided the many in the Declarations that Causes.

Slavery

1) every declaration renders the defense of enslavement a clear objective. 

Read more »


Mississippi

Our place is thoroughly identified with the institution of slavery-- the best material interest of the world. That is labor offers the product i beg your pardon constitutes by far the largest and most crucial portions of commerce of the earth… These products have come to be necessities of the world, and a blow at slavery is a blow at commerce and also civilization. The blow has actually been long aimed in ~ the institution, and was in ~ the suggest of reaching its consummation. There to be no an option left us but submission come the mandates that abolition, or a dissolved of the Union, whose values had been subverted to work out our ruin.

Texas

The servitude the the afri race, as existing in this States, is mutually valuable to both bond and free, and is abundantly authorized and also justified through the suffer of mankind, and the revealed will of the Almighty Creator, as well-known by all Christian nations.

South Carolina

Those States have actually assumed the appropriate of deciding ~ above the propriety of our domestic institutions; and also have denied the civil liberties of property developed in fifteen the the States and recognized through the Constitution; they have actually denounced together sinful the institution of slavery; they have permitted open up establishment amongst them that societies, whose avowed object is come disturb the peace and also to eloign the building of the citizens of various other States.

Georgia

That reason was fixed purpose to limit, restrain, and also finally abolish slavery in the states where the exists. The south with an excellent unanimity asserted her objective to withstand the principle of prohibition to the last extremity.


Georgia

We had acquired a large territory by effective war with Mexico; Congress had to administrate it; how, in relation to slavery, was the inquiry then demanding solution. Northern anti-slavery men of every parties check the right to exclude enslavement from the territory by conference legislation and demanded the prompt and also efficient practice of this power to that end. This insulting and also unconstitutional demand was met with great moderation and also firmness through the South. We had melted our blood and paid our money because that its acquisition; we demanded a department of it… or an same participation in the whole of it. The price the the acquisition was the blood and also treasure of both sections-- of all, and, therefore, the belonged to every upon the values of equity and justice.

Texas

The controlling majority of the commonwealth Government, under assorted pretenses and disguises, has so administered the same as to exclude the citizens of the southerly States, uneven under odious and also unconstitutional restrictions, from all the enormous territory own in common by every the states on the Pacific Ocean, because that the avowed function of acquiring sufficient power in the common government to usage it as a means of damaging the institutions of Texas and her sister slaveholding States.


Georgia

For twenty years past the abolitionists and also their allies in the northern States have actually been involved in continuous efforts to subvert our institutions and also to wake up insurrection and also servile war amongst us. … These initiatives have in one instance led come the actual intrusion of among the slave-holding States, and also those the the murderers and also incendiaries who escaped windy justice by trip have uncovered fraternal protection among our north confederates.

Mississippi

supporters negro equality, socially and also politically, and also promotes insurrection and also incendiarism in ours midst. It has actually enlisted that press, its pulpit and also its schools against us, until the whole popular psychic of the north is excited and inflamed with prejudice.

Texas

The human being have formed themselves into a good sectional party, now strong enough in numbers to regulate the work of each of those States, based ~ above an unnatural emotion of hostility come these southerly States and their beneficent and patriarchal mechanism of afri slavery, proclaiming the debasing theory of equality of every men, irrespective of gyeongju or color-- a doctrine at war v nature, in opposition to the suffer of mankind, and in violation that the plainest revelations of magnificent Law. They demand the abolition the negro enslavement throughout the confederacy, the acknowledgment of politics equality in between the white and also negro races, and avow their determination to press on your crusade versus us, so long as a black slave continues to be in these States... Lock have, through the mails and also hired emissaries, sent seditious pamphlets and also papers amongst us to stir increase servile insurrection and also bring blood and also carnage come our firesides.


4) Mississippi and Georgia point out that slavery accounts for a huge part of the southerly economy.

Read more »


Mississippi

We must either send to degradation, and also to the loss of property worth 4 billions the money, or we must secede native the Union framed by our fathers, to secure this and every other varieties of property.

Georgia

But they understand the worth of parchment rights in treacherous hands, and also therefore lock refuse to commit their very own to the rulers who the North supplies us. Why? since by their asserted principles and policy they have outlawed $3,000,000,000 of our property in the common territories the the Union; put it under the half of the Republic in the states where the exists and out of the defense of Federal law everywhere.


States" Rights

1) The says argue that the Union is a compact, one that deserve to be annulled if the states are no satisfied through what they obtain in return from other states and/or indigenous the commonwealth government.

Read an ext »


South Carolina

We hold...that the mode of that formation subjects it come a third an essential principle, namely: the law of compact. We maintain that in every compact in between two or more parties, the duty is mutual; the the failure of one of the contracting next to carry out a material component of the agreement, entirely releases the responsibility of the other; and also that wherein no arbiter is provided, every party is remitted come his own judgment to recognize the truth of failure, v all its consequences.

Georgia

Our structure wisely provides Congress the power to punish every offenses versus the regulations of nations. These room sound and just ethics which have received the approbation of simply men in every countries and also all centuries; yet they space wholly disregarded by the world of the north States, and the Federal federal government is impotent to preserve them.


2) The claims argue that the North"s reluctance to enforce the Fugitive servant Act of 1850 (mandating that fugitive servants be went back to the South) way that the compact is no much longer satisfactory.

Read an ext »


South Carolina

In the state of brand-new York also the best of transit because that a slave has been denied by she tribunals; and the says of Ohio and also Iowa have actually refused to surrender come justice fugitives charged with murder, and also with inciting servile insurrection in the State of Virginia. Thus the made up compact has actually been on purpose broken and disregarded through the non-slaveholding States, and also the consequence follows that south Carolina is released from her obligation.

Texas

The States… through solemn legislature enactments, have actually deliberately, straight or indirect violated the third clause the the second section that the fourth article of the commonwealth constitution, and also laws pass in pursuance thereof; in order to annulling a material provision the the compact, draft by its framers to perpetuate the amity between the members of the confederacy and to for sure the legal rights of the slave-holding states in their residential institutions-- a provision established in justice and also wisdom, and without the enforcement of i beg your pardon the compact fails to achieve the thing of that creation.


Other Grievances

1) every one of the states negatively cite Abraham Lincoln"s election and also his doubt abolitionist leanings.

Read more »


Georgia

This is the party to whom the world of the North have committed the Government. They raised their conventional in 1856 and also were barely defeated. They entered the Presidential dispute again in 1860 and also succeeded. The barred of slavery in the Territories, hostility to it everywhere, the equality that the black and also white races, neglect of all constitutional assures in its favor, were boldly proclaimed by its leaders and applauded by its followers.

South Carolina

On the fourth day of march next, this party will take possession of the Government. It has actually announced that the south shall it is in excluded native the typical territory, that the justice tribunals shall it is in made sectional, and that a war have to be waged versus slavery until it shall stop throughout the united States.

Texas

And, finally, through the an unified sectional poll of the seventeen non-slave-holding States, lock have chosen as president and also vice-president the the entirety confederacy two males whose chief insurance claims to together high positions room their approval of these long continued wrongs, and also their pledges to continue them come the final consummation of this schemes because that the damage of the slave-holding States.

Mississippi

It has recently obtained manage of the Government, by the start of that is unhallowed schemes, and destroyed the last expectation that living together in friendship and brotherhood. Utter subjugation awaits us in the Union, if we must consent much longer to continue to be in it.


2) Georgia accuses Northern production interests that exploiting the South and also dominating the commonwealth government.

Read more »


Georgia

The material prosperity of the north was greatly dependent ~ above the federal Government; that of the south not in ~ all. In the first years that the Republic the navigating, commercial, and manufacturing understanding of the North started to look for profit and also aggrandizement at the price of the farming interests. Even the owners of fishing smacks sought and obtained bounties for pursuing your own company (which however continue), and $500,000 is now paid them yearly out the the Treasury. The navigating interests begged because that protection against foreign shipbuilders and against competition in the coasting trade. Conference granted both requests, and also by prohibitory acts offered an absolute monopoly of this company to each of their interests, i m sorry they gain without diminution come this day. No content with these good and unjust advantages, they have actually sought to litter the legitimate burden of their business as much as feasible upon the public; they have actually succeeded in throwing the price of light-houses, buoys, and also the maintenance of their seamen upon the Treasury, and the federal government now pays above $2,000,000 yearly for the assistance of these objects. Theses interests, in link with the commercial and also manufacturing classes, have likewise succeeded, by method of subventions to letter steamers and the palliation in postage, in relieving their company from the payment of about $7,000,000 annually, throwing the upon the public Treasury under the name of postal deficiency. The production interests gotten in into the very same struggle early, and has clamored steadily for government bounties and special favors. This attention was confined largely to the Eastern and also Middle non-slave-holding States. Wielding these good States that held an excellent power and also influence, and its demands were in full proportion to its power. The manufacturers and also miners wisely based their needs upon unique facts and reasons rather than upon basic principles, and thereby mollified much of the the contrary of the the opposite interest. They pleaded in their favor the infancy of their service in this country, the scarcity the labor and capital, the hostile regulation of other countries toward them, the great necessity of your fabrics during war, and the need of high duties to pay the debt incurred in our battle for independence. These reasons prevailed, and also they received for countless years massive bounties by the basic acquiescence of the entirety country.


Texas

The commonwealth Government, while yet partially under the regulate of these our unnatural and sectional enemies, has actually for years virtually entirely fail to safeguard the lives and property that the human being of Texas against the Indian savages on our border, and more recently versus the murderous forays of banditti indigenous the surrounding territory of Mexico; and also when our State federal government has expended large amounts for such purpose, the Federal government has refuse reimbursement therefor, for this reason rendering our condition an ext insecure and harassing 보다 it was throughout the presence of the Republic of Texas.

See more: Why Do Spiral Galaxies Appear Blue In Color? Red Spirals Are Not Dead


Debates concerning the true causes of the polite War room unlikely to cease. Historians frequently cherry-pick evidence that support preconceived notions if ignoring big quantities of contradictory material. When that advertise is fueled by a enthusiasm desire to discover reconciliation and also consensus, as was the case after the civil War, the job-related of chroniclers becomes specifically murky. Primary sources such as the Declarations of causes are necessary to a well balanced study of history.